TL;DR
- Price perception is how customers interpret what you charge. They decide whether a price feels high, low or fair, and they draw conclusions about your offer’s quality and positioning from it.
- A price is justified when the design, copy and service behind it support it. The Ritz-Carlton can justify its prices because the entire experience that guests enjoy backs them up. Aldi couldn’t charge those prices because its stores couldn’t justify them.
- Your pricing model signals how premium, exclusive or accessible your business wants to be perceived.
- Constant discounting trains customers to wait. Genuine scarcity has the opposite effect. That’s where small businesses have an advantage.
- Transparent pricing builds trust, which small businesses can offer more easily.
What is price perception?
Price perception, sometimes also called pricing perception, means customers judge a price against what they expect, what the quality seems to be and what the alternatives cost, not against the number alone—so it’s relative. For example, a $6 coffee feels expensive at a drive-thru and perfectly reasonable in a boutique hotel lobby.
Researchers call the underlying mechanism the price-quality heuristic. It’s the mental shortcut that makes us perceive a higher price as a sign of better quality. In a 2008 study by Plassmann and colleagues, people rated the same wine as more pleasant when they were told it cost $45 instead of $5. The heuristic is related to the halo effect, where one good attribute subconsciously shapes how we judge everything else about a person or thing.
A price only works when the brand experience supports it
Let’s take the Ritz-Carlton as an example. The hotel brand wants to be perceived as exclusive, which is represented in its rates. But the higher price only works because everything behind it backs it up.
Co-founder Horst Schulze introduced a rule that let every employee, from housekeeping to the front desk staff, spend up to $2,000 per guest and incident to fix a problem without asking a manager. Schulze has said that the rule is rarely used. That’s beside the point. The rule gave employees the authority to act, which is how a housekeeper ended up flying to Hawaii to return a guest’s forgotten laptop. Schulze justified the amount with lifetime value, because a loyal guest was worth about $200,000 to the company.
Price perception examples from my work
To be transparent, I don’t set prices for my clients and I’m not involved in the process. In every project the price already exists, or is yet to be decided. My job is to create a brand that aligns with it. These three projects show how I take price perception into account in my branding work.
Südtirolhaus keeps a fair price approachable
Not every brand wants to look expensive. A brand that feels more exclusive than its prices are sends just as wrong a signal as one that looks cheaper than it is.
I worked with Südtirolhaus, a timber construction company in South Tyrol. They build beautiful, high-quality houses with prices comparable to other builders in the region.
The last thing we wanted was a brand that made potential customers feel they couldn’t afford to ask for a quote. In the brand refresh we kept the light green accents from the old brand, but we replaced the very dark grey with a lighter one. We also kept the former logo and cleaned it up, because it was already known in the region. What we added was an approachable feel, with rounded fonts and forms and an informal, friendly voice.
Rautner 1808 competes on location instead of price
Rautner 1808 is a vineyard and boutique accommodation with spa and event location on the outskirts of Bolzano. Tourism rules this part of Italy. There’s a farm stay on every second hillside, and many of them are lovely. Competing on price would send the wrong signal about a place as sophisticated as Rautner. It would also turn into a race to the bottom. Charging much higher prices than everyone else doesn’t feel right either.
So, we looked for another advantage, which we found in the location. Rautner is situated right between the vineyards and the city. It’s close enough to experience the best of both worlds. For a similar price to somewhere further out, Rautner is the obvious choice for anyone who wants the city within reach and the calm of the vineyards.
Office Flower Solutions sells less effort
Office Flower Solutions rents lifelike artificial flowers. The first objection they hear is why anyone would want to pay for fake flowers. But real flowers wilt, need looking after, and have to be grown, transported and replaced every week.
OFS’s founder Benjamin, on the other hand, comes by every month and swaps the arrangement for fresh ones. The flowers never wilt or make a mess, and they require no work at all. Subscriptions start from A$70 a month, depending on the size and number of arrangements.
For comparison, a Melbourne florist charges A$59 per delivery for a small seasonal bunch, which adds up to around A$236 a month if you want fresh flowers every week. Once you lay it out like that, customers compare the price with the effort real flowers take, which makes artificial flowers easier to accept.
That’s why it was really the copy that did most of the work. We chose a look and feel that’s elegant enough for businesses to trust and slightly cheeky, which shows the personality of the founder they deal with.
How pricing decisions shape price perception
Every pricing decision sends a signal about your brand. Let’s look at how they work, and what they do to price perception over time.
When a price change damages the brand
Toblerone shows how a hidden price rise can damage a brand. In 2016, facing rising ingredient costs, Mondelez cut the UK bar from 170g to 150g by spacing the triangles further apart. The company had weighed changing the shape against raising the price. Of course, customers noticed straight away, and the story reportedly topped BBC News’ most-read list—even on US election day.
Almost two years later the original shape was reintroduced at 200g. The 150g bar had cost £1, and the new one was expected to retail at £2.50, or £2 on promotion. That’s a price rise of at least 50% by weight. So in the end they raised the price anyway.
Why discounting damages price perception
Low prices work if the brand is built around them. Constant discounting, on the other hand, does long-term damage.
This is well-studied. Mela, Gupta and Lehmann examined the long-term effects of promotion and advertising on brand choice in the Journal of Marketing Research in 1997, using more than eight years of panel data for one frequently purchased packaged good. They found that consumers became more sensitive to price and promotions over time as advertising was reduced and promotions increased.
A follow-up by Mela, Gupta and Jedidi (International Journal of Research in Marketing, 1998) showed that more promotions and less advertising reduced the differentiation between brands. Jedidi, Mela and Gupta (Marketing Science, 1999) found that in the long term, advertising has a positive effect on brand equity while promotions have a negative one. Repeated discounting makes a brand feel interchangeable with other brands on the shelf.
Living in New Zealand, I can’t remember the last time I saw Kathmandu without a sale on. Ultimately, the sale price became the real price and you’d be silly to pay the original price. Once customers have learned to wait for the sale, most of them keep waiting.
Genuine scarcity doesn’t train customers to wait
Let me give you an example. I’ve been trying to order from Le Bon Shoppe for over a year. Shipping to New Zealand is expensive, so I keep waiting to combine a few pieces, but the ones I want are always sold out. What’s interesting is that I’m not waiting for a sale, because I know one isn’t coming. It’s more that when the items are finally available, you have to grab them while they last.
That’s the difference between scarcity that’s genuine and scarcity that irritates people. Countdown timers and messages saying “only three left in stock” are usually a ploy—and customers can tell. Real scarcity means a limited quantity, limited drops or limited availability of a service that people actually want, which small businesses do naturally. Scarcity is also one of Cialdini’s six principles of influence.
Low prices work when the brand is built around them
There’s a way of offering low prices that doesn’t compromise quality—when customers can see where the savings come from.
- IKEA’s prices make sense because the flat packaging reduces shipping costs and self-assembly reduces labour costs.
- Aldi offers a fraction of the products bigger supermarkets do, which means larger orders and lower purchase prices.
Small brands can use the same logic, for example:
- As a freelancer rather than an agency, I can offer lower prices because I don’t have the overheads.
- A DTC brand with an excellent website but no physical shop has a valid reason to charge less because there’s no middleman or store.
- A made-to-order brand has no unsold stock to write off, so it doesn’t need to build that cost into its prices.
- A café with a small menu wastes less food and needs less prep, which keeps its prices down.
Showing where a price comes from builds trust
Today’s customers compare and research, and they expect to be told things. Hidden fees, confusing structures and inflated discounts create scepticism, and scepticism is expensive.
Buffer built transparency into its pricing model by showing where the money from each subscription goes. It reinforces the openness the brand is known for and reassures people they’re not being taken for a ride.
You can do the same on a smaller scale by explaining what goes into your price, such as your time, your materials and the process behind the work.
Price perception, brand equity and elasticity
Two related concepts explain why the same price can feel fine for one brand and too high for another.
Brand equity
Brand equity is the intangible value of a brand, built from awareness, trust and perceived value. A brand with strong equity can generally charge more.
Pricing feeds back into equity too. A brand seen as high quality gets its perception reinforced by its price. Constant discounts dilute equity, as the studies above show, and make a business look inconsistent, or a bit desperate.
Price elasticity
Price elasticity is how much demand moves when the price does. Strong, differentiated brands can raise prices with little drop-off. Weaker ones lose customers over small increases. Pic’s Peanut Butter shows what that pricing power looks like. It launched at nearly twice the price of its competitors and now holds 41% of the New Zealand market.
- Elastic: Small price changes have a big effect on demand. Common in crowded markets with price-sensitive customers, like low-cost airlines or fast fashion.
- Inelastic: Demand holds despite a price rise. Common for differentiated brands with real pricing power, like luxury goods or niche products.
Building pricing power ultimately comes down to differentiation and brand strength.
Pricing strategies and techniques at a glance
Which pricing strategy you choose and how you present the price both shape how customers perceive it. The following overview shows the common techniques and what they signal about your brand. I won’t go into detail.
Pricing strategies
Every model below signals something about your positioning, before you’ve said a word about it yourself.
By position in the market
- Premium: Price above everyone else and ask your whole brand to carry the number. Ferrari.
- Economy: Price low and wide, and make the reason visible. IKEA’s flat pack is part of the offer.
- Masstige: Prestige at a price that lets more people in. The BMW 1 Series opens the door to the badge.
- Competitive: Price just under the competition and win on something else. Casper cut out the mattress store.
- Parity: Match your competitor and argue somewhere else. Samsung charges what Apple charges and lets the cameras do the talking.
By pricing logic
- Value-based: Price against the outcome the customer gets. It’s why a rare-disease drug costs what it does, and why a consultant might price against the revenue a project generates instead of the hours it takes.
- Dynamic: Let demand set the price. Uber in the rain, or a photographer charging more for a Saturday in peak season than for a Tuesday in the off-season.
- Pay-what-you-want: Hand the decision over entirely. Atipo Foundry sells most of its font families this way, and Radiohead released In Rainbows this way. It only works if the goodwill is already there.
By payment model
- Freemium: Give away the basics, charge for the rest. Spotify.
- Tier: Serve very different customers off the same product. Mailchimp runs from solo founder to mid-sized company, and a studio offering a small brand refresh next to a full strategy package is doing the same thing.
- Subscription: Trade a small recurring fee for predictable income. Netflix and Adobe, but also a freelance retainer.
By timing
- Skimming: Start high, ease down. The original iPhone launched at $599 and cost $399 ten weeks later.
- Penetration: Start low to win people fast, then raise once they’re loyal. Office Flower Solutions, my client example from before, gives many new customers an introductory discount, before charging regular prices.
Psychological pricing techniques
These tap into cognitive biases and make a price feel different without changing what’s behind it.
- Anchoring: Show a higher-priced option first and everything after it looks reasonable. A hotel offering a $500 suite before a $250 room makes the second feel like good value. Charm pricing below relies on a similar effect.
- Charm pricing: $9.95 rather than $10 feels smaller, because we anchor on the first digit. It works best on practical, price-sensitive purchases. When people buy with emotion, such as gifts and treats, round prices feel more correct.
- The compromise effect: A third, much pricier option pushes people towards the middle. A café pricing coffee at $3, $4.50 and $7 sells a lot of mediums.
- Bundling: Several products at a combined price below the sum of the parts, which makes the offer feel generous and gets people buying more than planned.
- Loss aversion: People work harder to avoid losing something than to gain the same thing. A designer might frame this as the cost of staying invisible instead of the price of a rebrand.
Use these carefully. Every one of them can tip into manipulation, and customers who feel played will hold it against you far longer than they’d hold a higher price.
Aligning pricing with your brand
Pricing is a strategic tool. It needs to reflect your positioning in the market and reinforce that over time.
Low prices attract bargain hunters, and bargain hunters leave when another brand undercuts you. Brands with a strong foundation can raise prices without losing people, because the price was never the only reason their customers chose them.
Honest, consistent pricing does more for a brand than any single discount ever will. But it never works alone. It’s one signal among many, and it only supports your brand when the strategy, the design and the copy are all saying the same thing.
I develop strategy, design and copy together, as one service, in English and German, for a small number of clients each year. As part of that, I make sure the brand reflects your prices. Tell me about your business and I’ll be honest about whether I’d be the right fit.
Frequently asked questions
How do I raise my prices without losing clients?
Raise them for new clients first, and give existing ones notice rather than a surprise invoice. Besides, clients who chose you for your positioning, offer or results are far less likely to leave over a reasonable increase than clients who chose you on price alone.
How often should you raise your prices?
Once a year is a reasonable default for most small businesses and freelancers, in line with rising costs and growing experience. If demand consistently outpaces your capacity, that’s a sign your price is below what the market thinks your work is worth. That said, I’m not a big believer in the idea that the economy has to grow every year, so if your costs are covered, you don’t need to raise your prices annually.
How do I stop discounting without losing sales?
Replace the discount with added value, such as a bonus service, a faster turnaround, a limited drop or another special extra. It protects the price customers associate with your business while still giving them a reason to buy.
If customers have already learned to wait for a sale, pull the discounts back gradually until the regular price feels normal again. Sometimes a rebrand can also mark this change in your strategy and signal to customers that the days of constant deals are over.
Title image by Kaboompics